By:
Subhash
K.
Jha,
IndiaFM
Friday,
September
29,
2006
Shiva
has
been
a
disappointment.
I
wanted
to
make
formula
film.
I
was
true
to
my
intent.
The
kind
of
budget
it
was
made
in,
my
distributors
are
happy.
As
for
the
critics,
I
compensated
for
the
pain
I
caused
them
in
watching
the
film
in
the
pleasure
that
they
got
in
ripping
me
apart.
So
everyone
is
happy.
Having
said
that
I
think
it
was
wrong
of
me
to
regress
into
a
formula
film
after
having
gone
so
far
ahead
in
Satya,
Company
and
Sarkar.
I
admit
it
was
a
mistake
to
make
Shiva.
See,
a
film
is
made
in
a
particular
state
of
mind.
Shiva
was
made
as
an
immediate
reaction
to
the
failure
of
James.
The
whole
basis
of
making
Shiva
was
wrong.
Do
you
think
you
might
one
day
admit
re-making
Sholay
was
a
mistake?
See,
the
best
thing
to
happen
to
my
Sholay
was
the
flopping
of
Shiva.
It
put
me
on
high
alert.
If
Shiva
had
worked
I'd
have
become
complacent.
I
don't
think
making
an
anti-establishment
cop
flick
in
Shiva
was
wrong.
The
execution
and
characterizations
were
too
status-quo.
In
Sholay
I'm
very
clear
what
I
want
to
do
and
don't
want
to
do.
It
has
been
brewing
in
my
mind
for
three
years.
I
admit
I
was
being
cocky
in
making
Shiva.
I
thought
mera
baayen
haath
ka
khel
hai,
whereas
I
know
how
difficult
it
is
to
make
my
own
version
of
Sholay.
A
lot
of
very
important
people
believe
Sholay
shouldn't
be
re-made...
Do
they?
Sorry,
I
can't
oblige
them.
People
don't
know
what
I'm
making,
so
they're
just
reacting
nostalgically.
Everyone
from
Jayaji
and
Dharamji
to
my
other
well-wishers
have
advised
me
to
stay
away
from
Sholay.
Dharamji
has
apparently
said
he'd
jump
off
that
water
tank
if
I
messed
up
Sholay.
Why
should
he
jump
off?
He
should
push
me
off
that
tank
if
I
mess
up
with
Sholay.
I've
made
humungous
preparations!
Nothing
in
my
Sholay
would
be
the
same
as
the
earlier
Sholay.
For
example
there's
no
Basanti
in
my
Sholay.
What
do
you
mean?
If
you
remove
the
tonga
and
ghagra-choli
from
Basanti
she's
just
another
girl
in
the
plot.
A
lot
of
characters
in
Gabbar's
gang
will
be
fleshed
out.
Sambha
is
very
different.
Likewise
the
first
cop
who
comes
to
meet
Thakur
is
far
more
important
in
my
film.
My
film
has
a
strong
police
presence
because
it's
set
in
the
city.
A
lot
of
cynics
say
you're
making
up
the
Sholay
re-make?
Some
said
I'm
faking
it
because
I
don't
have
the
copyrights.
95
percent
people
have
nothing
to
do,
so
they
create
constant
hallucinations
about
other
people's
work.
I'm
starting
Sholay
on
4
October.
I'll
start
with
scenes
featuring
Mr
Bachchan
as
Gabbar
Singh.
You've
no
idea
how
excited
Mr
Bachchan
is.
What
kind
of
get-up
will
Mr
Bachchan
sport?
Of
course
Gabbar
has
to
be
terror.
So
Mr
Bachchan
will
have
elaborate
get-up.
This
is
such
a
larger-than-life
story.
Everyone
has
to
be
many
sizes
larger
than
life.
You'll
feel
his
viciousness.
All
these
years
Mr
Bachchan
has
hidden
his
evil
side
so
well.
I
want
to
bring
it
out
on
screen.
How
can
anyone
be
so
correct?
No
one
can
be
so
morally
perfect.
So
you're
going
ahead
with
Sholay?
People
say
I'm
not
capable
of
re-making
Sholay.
I've
one
consolation
for
them.
Since
the
critics
have
already
exhausted
all
their
expletives
for
Shiva,
they'd
have
nothing
left
to
say
about
Sholay.
I
think
they'll
pool
their
money
and
hire
a
gangster
to
get
rid
of
me.
If
Allah,
Jesus
Christ
and
Vaishno
Devi
come
together
to
plead
against
my
doing
Sholay
I'm
still
be
making
it.
Aage
jo
hoga
wohdekha
jayega
.