By:
Subhadeep
Bhattacharjee
Friday,
October
12,
2007
Is
Bollywood
out
of
new
ideas
or
its
just
easy
to
copy
form
a
successful
movie.
If
recent
trends
are
anything
to
go
by
than
it
seems
Bollywood
has
stopped
making
movies
on
new
ideas.
Let
us
look
at
some
of
the
recent
movies
where
the
directors
have
borrowed
(read
copied!)
the
treatment
from
other
movies.
Saawariya
This
incidentally
comes
from
one
of
the
most
respected
directors
in
the
industry.
It
draws
inspiration
from
a
short
story
Le
notti
bianche
(White
Nights)
by
Fyodor
Dostoyevsky.
Italian
director
Luchino
Visconti
creatively
treated
it
and
made
a
movie
in
1957.
French
director
Robert
Bresson
in
the
year
1971
transformed
the
movie
into
a
block
buster
Quatre
nuits
d'un
reveur
(Four
Nights
of
a
Dreamer)
The
story
revolves
around
a
girl
who
falls
in
love
with
a
stranger
and
wants
to
get
married
to
him
and
proposes
marriage.
The
boy
refuses
due
to
lack
of
funds
but
promises
to
be
back
after
a
year.
Ranbir
Kapoor
and
Sonam
Kapoor
play
the
lead
in
this
Bhansali
movie.
Lagaa
Chunari
Mein
Daag
Director
Pradeep
Sarkar
whose
movie
Parineeta
was
also
a
remake
does
it
again
with
Laaga
Chunari
Mein
Daag.
His
inspiration
Aaina
starring
Mumtaz,
Rajesh
Khanna,
A
K
Hangal
and
Nirupa
Roy.
In
the
original
a
girl's
(Mumtaz)
father
prevents
her
from
marrying
a
lower
class
boy
(Rajesh
Khanna)
who
later
gets
killed
while
in
the
army.
The
girl
goes
to
the
city
in
search
of
work
and
gets
into
prostitution.
In
the
remake
Rani
Mukherjee
and
her
sister
(Konkana)
are
shown
struggling
in
Benaras.
Rani
then
undertakes
the
journey
to
the
city
and
gets
into
prostitution
to
support
her
sisters
education.
The
only
difference
is
that
Rani
meets
the
lover
in
the
city.
Om
Shanti
Om
Farah
Khan
looked
for
her
inspiration
towards
Hollywood
and
got
it
from
Chances
Are
directed
by
Emile.
In
the
original
the
Christopher
McDonald
and
the
Cybill
Shepherd
are
happily
married
when
tragedy
strikes
and
Christopher
gets
killed
in
a
road
accident.
He
is
reborn
and
falls
in
love
with
his
own
daughter
Mary
Stuart
Masterson.
He
remembers
his
past
life
when
he
comes
to
Mary's
house
but
her
mother
has
grown
old
and
cannot
recognize
him.
In
Om
Shanti
Om
Deepika
is
a
huge
star
of
the
1970s
and
Shahrukh
plays
a
junior
artist
and
they
fall
in
love.
Shahrukh
gets
murdered
and
is
reborn
and
than
goes
in
search
of
his
lost
love
Jab
We
Met
Jab
We
Met
draws
its
inspiration
from
multiple
sources.
The
idea
has
been
extensively
tried
both
in
Hollywood
and
Bollywood.
It
can
be
compared
to
It
Happened
One
Night
by
Frank
Capra,
Dil
Hai
Ki
Manta
Nahi
by
Mahesh
Bhatt,
Pyar
Toh
Hona
Hi
Tha,
A
Walk
In
The
Clouds,
French
Kiss
Jab
We
Met
is
directed
by
Imtiaz
Ali
and
stars
ex
love
birds
Kareena
Kapoor
and
Shahid
Kapoor.
The
story
is
of
a
girl
who
runs
away
from
home
to
marry
her
love.
On
the
way
she
meets
another
man
who
is
willing
to
help
her
reunite
with
her
boyfriend.
The
hate
each
other
in
the
beginning
and
in
the
end
well
any
guess?
Wanted:
Dead
or
Alive
Wanted
Dead
or
Alive
is
a
movie
inspired
by
the
2006
Telugu
blockbuster
Pokiri
staring
Mahesh
Babu,
Ileana
D'Cruz,
Prakash
Raj.
The
hindi
remnake
will
be
done
by
the
dancing
sensation
Prabhu
Deva
and
produced
by
Boney
Kapoor.
The
movie
will
star
Salman
Khan,
Ayesha
Takia,
Om
Puri,
Mahesh
Manjrekar
and
Sayaji
Shinde.
The
story
is
about
an
undercover
cop
who
works
as
a
henchman
and
soon
meets
the
heroine
and
falls
in
love
with
her.
But
when
she
wants
to
declare
her
love
he
is
is
attacked
by
a
gang
whom
he
kills
and
terrifies
his
lady
love.
One
thing
which
is
evident
is
that
a
story
never
dies
it
is
reincarnated
time
and
again
in
Bollywood.