Is Bollywood Anti-capitalism?
By:
Screen
Weekly,
IndiaFM
Monday,
March
05,
2007
Given
the
contemporary
issues
and
ideological
stances
adopted
by
Hindi
films
these
days,
Bollywood
demands
to
be
taken
seriously.
Last
year's
big
hits,
Rang
De
Basanti
and
Lage
Raho
Munnabhai,
have
received
a
fair
amount
of
attention
but
the
recent
release,
Guru,
seems
to
have
been
smothered
by
news
of
the
impending
marriage
of
its
co-stars.
Which
is
a
pity,
because
it
is
a
film
that
needs
to
be
taken
note
of,
not
because
it
is
probably
the
first
time
an
Indian
film
has
dealt
in
a
realistic
manner
with
recent
events
involving
powerful,
controversial
personalities
-
the
closest
parallel
one
can
think
of
is
the
fleeting
presence
of
the
Modi-like
character
in
Parzania
and
films
such
as
Nayakan,
Company
and
Black
Friday,
all
of
which
recreated
underworld
figures
which
is
perhaps
not
quite
the
same
thing
as
making
a
film
on
the
life
of
Dhirubhai
Ambani
-
but
because,
in
its
blatant
ideological
thrust,
Guru
is
possibly
one
of
the
most
unusual
films
ever
made
in
the
history
of
popular
cinema.
The climax where Guru gives a rousing speech, casting himself as a rebel and a man of the people in the Gandhian mould and promising to build the world's largest company.
The parallel is patently specious. It is absurd to imagine Gandhi pointing to material goals as Guru does or using ends to justify unethical means. Yet there is no evidence of irony on the part of the filmmaker. Guru emerges larger than life. Why is this unusual?
For starters try keying in 'capitalist films' into Google. What you would get is a host of websites discussing anti-capitalism films. With some luck and many tries later, you could find your way to a website specialising in 'rare, special films' that have four series on offer: Red Scare on cold war propaganda, capitalist propaganda - all cartoons, Capitalist Propaganda 2 ('some of these have to be seen to be believed') and Yellow Peril, four 'fascinating' propaganda films that come with the warning: 'this is not politically correct'. My point: to root for capitalism in cinema is not and has never been politically correct.
It is hard to think of realistic biopics of capitalists in Bollywood but from the zamindar to the smuggler in Deewar and the upwardly mobile middle class duo in Yes Boss, greed has not been rewarded. Hollywood is perhaps an even more appropriate place to test the hypothesis. Consider the great American films made on the capitalist theme. In Orson Welles's Citizen Kane, the wealthy newspaper owner dies a sad, lonely death. In Fritz Lang's Metropolis, the industrialist is a tyrant ruling over robot-like workers. In film versions of classics like Theodore Dreiser's An American Tragedy and Tom Wolfe's Bonfire of the Vanities and in the archetypal '80s drama, Wall Street, the greedy protagonist meets with a sad end. Pretty Woman, Erin Brokovich, The Pelican Brief and The Insider are just some examples of Hollywood's penchant for casting the capitalist in a bad light. Even the rare films that seem to buck the trend (The Secret of My Success) have a goofy theme which successfully undercuts the triumph of capitalism. In fact, Larry E. Ribstein, professor of law at the University of Illinois, in a 2004 paper entitled 'Why Does Business Look Bad in Movies' claims, "Film's attitude towards business has remained relatively constant despite the changing demographics of film audiences."
Ribstein's explanation for this unlikely phenomenon in the world's greatest capitalist enterprise is that the artist, frustrated by commercial constraints, sees film as a vehicle through which to vent frustration. There is also the belief that with the emergence of new sources of film financing (TV, product placement, venture funding), the anti-capitalist bias in cinema will diminish. So the question is: why did Mani Ratnam decide to make such a break with the past? Was it to reflect contemporary reality or is Guru a harbinger of a new cinematic future shorn of the artist's angst?
Recent
Stories
Yuvika
Chaudhary
gears
for
her
debut
Heyy
Babyy!
It's
party
time!