Those
millions
who
have
read
Chetan
Bhagat"s
book
novel
Five
Point
Someone
would
agree
that
there
are
uncanny
resemblances
between
the
novel
and
Raj
Kumar
Hirani"s
3
Idiots.The
film
apparently
set
out
to
adapt
Bhagat"s
novel
and
then
decided
to
go
its
own
way,
for
whatever
reasons.
Now
to
his
horror
Chetan
Bhagat
finds
his
name
missing
from
the
opening
credits
of
3
Idiots.
Not
only
that,
both
producer
Vidhu
Vinod
Chopra
and
Aamir
Khan
have
gone
on
record
to
accuse
the
bestselling
author
of
trying
to
gain
publicity
from
the
film.
Hurt
and
amused
Chetan
reacts.
You
must
be
very
upset
by
the
latest
proceedings?
You"re
a
writer.
You
should
know
how
it
feels
to
have
credit
taken
away
from
you.
And
it"s
not
something
only
I"m
saying.
It"s
out
there.
The
book
is
there.
The
film
is
there.
They"ve
tried
to
take
away
from
my
contribution.
My
name
is
at
the
very
end
of
the
credit
titles
after
the
junior
artistes
and
still
photographers.
From
the
time
they
started
making
the
film
they"ve
been
stressing
that
their
product
is
different.
It"s
like
a
systematic
effort
(to
underplay
my
contribution).
If
you
read
the
book
and
saw
the
film
you"ll
see
the
similarities.
So
would
you
say
3
Idiots
is
an
adaptation
of
your
novel?
3
Idiots
is
a
total
adaptation
of
my
book.
Some
things
are
direct
lifts,
others
indirect
adaptations.
Aamir
thinks
you
are
trying
to
take
away
credit
from
the
film"s
writer
Abhijat
Joshi?I
heard
his
comments.
But
then
he
says
he
hasn"t
read
the
book.
There"s
no
denying
Abhijat
has
done
the
screenplay.
What
Abhijat
has
done
with
my
book
can
only
be
known
if
you"ve
read
it.
If
Aamir
is
so
concerned
about
Abhijat
not
getting
the
publicity
he
should
let
Abhijat
talk.
I
very
much
respect
Aamir.
He"s
the
reason
I
thought
the
project
would
have
a
lot
of
integrity.
I
know
for
a
fact
he
was
told
not
to
read
my
book
because
they
told
him
it"d
affect
his
understanding
of
the
story.
I
was
told
it
was
a
different
script.
How
would
Aamir"s
perception
have
been
affected
if
he
read
the
book?
I
don"t
know.
I"m
on
a
firm
footing
with
the
facts.
See
the
film,
read
the
book.
And
judge
for
yourself.
The
whole
plot
structure,
narrative,
even
dialogues
about
matar-paneer
and
Maruti
800
cars
are
from
my
novel.
The
novel
was
set
in
the
1990s.
Aaj
Maruti
800
kaun
bolega?
I
mention
42
exams
and
16
broken
bones
in
my
book.
They
have
kept
the
same
numbers
in
the
film.
Kareena"s
brother
committing
suicide
on
the
railway
tracks…so
many
other
things
in
the
film,
which
are
all
there
in
my
novel.
Vidhu
Vinod
Chopra
and
Aamir
have
accused
you
of
trying
to
make
mileage
out
of
their
movie?
If
I
didn"t
take
up
the
issue
properly
I
wouldn"t
have
been
able
to
live
with
myself.
If
someone
else
goes
and
collects
the
award
for
best
story
at
the
awards
functions
how
will
I
feel?
Only
once
I
met
Aamir
which
was
when
I
landed
at
Bangalore
where
they
were
shooting
3
Idiots
and
I
was
told,
'Don"t
come
we"ve
too
many
visitors".They
prevented
me
from
going
on
the
set.
The
book
has
been
selling
for
six
years.
There"re
lakhs
of
fans
of
the
book.
It"s
not
about
Chetan
being
naraaz
and
Aamir
being
naraaz.
My
issue
is
not
with
Aamir.
When
the
other
film
Hello
based
on
my
novel
One
Night
At
The
Call
Centre
came
did
I
say
one
word
against
the
characterizations
or
treatment?
I
was
credited
properly
for
that
but
I
haven"t
been
credited
for
3
Idiots.
Have
you
become
embittered
towards
Bollywood?
You
could
make
up
any
kind
of
contract.
But
is
there
any
contract
that
stops
people
from
being
petty?
My
last
novel
The
3
Mistakes
Of
My
Life
is
being
directed
by
Abhishek
Kapoor
and
I
am
co-scripting
it.
There"s
a
lot
of
interest
in
adapting
my
latest
novel
2
States:
The
Story
Of
My
Marriage.
I
don"t
think
there
would
be
any
problem
with
future
project.
With
3
Idiots
I
know
I"m
in
the
right.
I"m
just
telling
people
to
see
the
film
and
read
my
book.
I
know
Aamir
is
a
very
powerful
person.
But
finally
the
truth
has
to
prevail,
no?
I"m
no
great
artiste.
But
there
has
to
be
fair
play.
I"m
being
accused
of
trying
to
get
mileage.10
lakh
copies
of
the
book
have
been
sold.
The
book
has
been
read
by
1
crore
readers.
Wouldn"t
they
know
the
truth?
What
do
you
intend
to
do?
The
makers
of
3
Idiots
are
busy
with
their
victory
tours
all
over
the
country.
They"re
naturally
being
asked
about
the
similarities
between
my
book
and
the
film.
Sorry
I
spoilt
their
celebrations.
The
truth
had
to
be
told.
I"ve
been
told
by
them,
'You"re
just
a
writer.
You
don"t
realize
how
big
we
are." Maybe
I
don"t
realize
how
big
they
are.
Main
kya
karoon?
But
the
truth
is
above
everything.
Aisa
nahin
ke
pura
Bollywood
kharaab
hai.
Do
you
think
you"ll
be
ostracized
by
Bollywood
after
this
incident?
I"m
not
dependent
on
Bollywood
for
my
livelihood.
I"m
a
big
Krishna
bhakt.
I"ll
follow
the
right
path.
If
I"m
wrong
I"ll
leave
writing
and
join
ISKCON.
A
writer
just
wants
that
his
words
should
make
a
change
in
the
society.
Maybe
by
taking
up
this
issue
I
hope
to
bring
about
a
change
in
the
way
writers
are
treated.
Vidhu
Vinod
Chopra
assured
me
he
would
treat
me
like
a
king.
Kahan
ka
raja?
What
do
you
hope
to
achieve?
When
they
go
to
pick
up
the
story
award
I
want
people
to
know
whose
story
it
is.
When
they
make
eye
contact
with
their
children
they
should
know
they"re
lying.
We"ve
to
show
that
truth
comes
before
everything
else.
I
don"t
write
for
money
or
glamour.
I
just
need
paper
and
pen.
Lord
Krishna
takes
care
of
the
rest.