Filmmaker
Sudhir
Mishra
who
has
been
working
on
a
film
on
Binayak
Sen's
life
is
shocked
to
hear
of
activist's
life-imprisonment
on
sedition
charges.
Sudhir
has
studied
Sen's
life
closely.
Asks
Sudhir,
"What's
the
true
definition
of
sedition?
I
don't
understand
it.
I've
met
Binayak
Sen
when
I
was
a
young
man.
Now
when
he
was
out
on
bail,
I
met
him
again.
Binayak
Sen
is
a
very
warm
gentle
soul,
not
given
to
rhetorics
at
all.
He's
very
quiet.
He's
an
army
officer's
son
for
God's
sake!
He
is
my
best
friend's
elder
brother.
I
was
told
to
be
like
Binayak-da.
He's
a
brilliant
paediatrician.
He
could
have
been
in
Mumbai
and
made
millions
as
a
doctor.
Instead
he
chose
to
listen
to
Gandhiji
and
went
to
the
village.
Is
this
what
he
gets
for
his
idealism?"
Upset,
yes.
But
Sudhir
is
hopeful
that
justice
would
prevail.
"The
National
Advisory
Council
to
Mrs
Sonia
Gandhi
is
saying
this
is
not
right.
They
say
the
evidence
against
Binayak
Sen
is
very
scant.
What
can
I
say?
I
am
so
glad
there
has
been
a
surge
of
protest
against
the
verdict.
At
least
the
voice
of
dissent
is
alive
in
India.
I
am
not
too
enamoured
of
Amnesty
and
other
international
agencies
jumping
in
to
protest.
I
don't
always
agree
with
them.
But
the
voice
of
dissent
in
India
is
reassuring.
A
lot
of
people
believe
Binayak-da
is
not
guilty
as
charged.
I
believe
them."
Sudhir
feels
through
debate
on
Sen's
guilt/non-guilt
we
can
arrive
at
a
consensus
on
how
to
deal
with
the
'Other
India'.
Says
Sudhir,
"We
in
the
cities
live
in
the
barbed
seclusion
of
bungalows
and
watchmen
cut
off
from
the
reality
of
the
grassroots
levels.
In
any
political
system
there
has
to
be
debate."
Sudhir
Mishra
thinks
the
voice
of
dissent
is
not
strong
enough
in
India,
not
even
in
the
artistic
world.
"Look
at
Oliver
Stone
in
America.
His
film
JFK
can
be
perceived
as
a
seditious
act!
Stone
feels
the
official
point
of
view
needs
a
counter-view.
And
he
represents
that
view.
He
is
saying,
here's
my
point
of
view
listen
to
it.
That's
democracy."
Sudhir
Mishra
has
no
empathy
or
patience
with
Naxalism.
He
does
have
a
solution,
though.
"I've
no
interest
or
appetite
for
extremist
violence.
I
think
the
way
out
is
to
have
a
dialogue
with
people
like
Binayak
Sen.
Since
a
person
like
Binayak-da
understands
those
areas
where
Naxalism
exists,
he'd
be
the
right
person
to
find
a
solution.
It's
like
Nitish
Kumar
in
Bihar.
The
moment
people
saw
him
to
be
sincere,
caste
ceased
to
matter
and
they
voted
for
him
in
one
voice.
In
some
ways,
I
find
Nitish
and
Binayak
similar.
They
both
represent
a
certain
hope
for
a
section."
Then
Sudhir
Mishra
offers
a
startling
solution
to
the
Indian
socio-political
deadlock.
"I
think
the
solution
to
the
present-day
crisis
lies
with
Rahul
Gandhi,
Nitish
Kumar
and
Binayak
Sen.
One
of
them
understands
the
young
mind,
the
other
comes
from
the
establishment
and
understands
the
grass
root
reality,
and
the
third
is
a
dissenter.
They
should
have
a
serious
conversation."
Sudhir
feels
Binayak's
matter
should
now
go
to
the
Supreme
Court.
"The
Supreme
Court
of
India
has
shown
great
vision
and
impartiality
in
the
past.
All
of
us
who
want
to
protest
about
Binayak
Sen's
sentencing
should
express
our
dissent
through
the
Supreme
Court
Of
India."
Sudhir
is
keener
than
ever
to
make
the
film
on
Binayak
Sen's
life.
"But
no
one
will
fund
it.
I
wanted
to
make
a
film
on
what
gives
birth
to
a
figure
like
Binayak
Sen.
I
wanted
to
understand
what
motivates
such
a
mind.
The
cinema
with
a
conscience
and
about
the
conscience
like
Satyajit
Ray's
Pather
Panchali
and
Hrishikesh
Mukherjee's
Satyakam
is
almost
lots
to
us.
We
need
to
retrieve
that
cinema."
Story first published: Thursday, January 6, 2011, 15:24 [IST]