The
positives
of
Guzaarish,
featuring
Hrithik
Roshan
and
Aishwarya
Bachchan,
is
that
its
craft
and
direction
is
spectacular
and
flawless,
the
actors
are
more
than
convincing
and
this
is
the
first
movie
on
a
spinal
injured-
a
quadriplegic
in
Indian
cinema.
The
images
are
real
and
flawless
–
the
accident,
topple
from
the
bed,
helplessness
at
the
leaking
roof,
feeling
the
fresh
air
outdoors
and
many
other
such
images.
A
film
is
both
a
potent
tool
for
transforming
mindsets
and
can
sometimes
also
don
the
role
of
weapons
of
mass
destruction.
We
need
the
best
in
the
industry
to
project
and
showcase
more
responsible
cinema.
As
a
person
with
spinal
injury
and
as
the
founder
of
our
NGO,
Nina
Foundation,
I
would
not
recommend
Guzaarish
to
my
friends
with
spinal
injury.
I
will
elaborate
this
rationale:
1.
It"s
a
non-
Indian
take.
The
biggest
motivating
factor
for
a
traumatic
spinal
injured
is
his
ring
of
FAMILY.
The
entire
family
rallies
around
and
forms
a
ring
of
support
both
physical
and
emotional.
The
independent
living
concept
shown
in
the
movie
with
Ethan
living
with
only
caretakers
and
caregivers
is
remote.
More
than
one
member
of
the
family
takes
charge
and
enables
one
to
sail
through
life
happily.
2.
We
have
glowing
examples
of
Indian
quadriplegics
living
with
this
life
transforming
disability
for
more
than
12
years
(the
number
in
Guzaarish).
Maj
HP
S
Ahluwalia,
Rajendra
Johar,
Sruti
Mohapatra,
Subramaniam,
Arvind
Prabhoo,
Nishant
Khade,
Abdulla
and
I
can
go
on.
They
have
families,
friends
and
successful
careers
and
goals
and
are
leading
successful
lives.
3.
Disability
is
an
'untouchable"
'invisible" taboo
concept
in
India.
The
movie
with
its
ending
propagates
this
very
concept.
That
a
human
being
and
his
wishes
are
above
the
law?
A
disabled
is
better
off
ending
his
life?
Obstacles
and
problems
should
taint
our
view
about
life?
Spinal
injury
is
too
big
a
problem
to
live
with?
4.
Our
NGO
is
attempting
to
create
interest,
involvement
and
inspiration
amongst
friends
with
spinal
injury.
Believe
me,
it's
an
uphill
task.
It
takes
hours
and
years
to
convince
how
to
overcome
our
daily
problems
and
yet
lead
a
life
of
happiness
and
dignity.
Guzaarish"s
depressing
tone
nullifies
that
in
three
hours.
Despite
being
financially
independent
(Ethan
has
written
a
book,
has
a
radio
show),
he
wants
to
end
his
life.
5.India
is
the
capital
of
people
with
spinal
injury,
over
15
lakhs
and
we
add
20,000
every
year.
Most
are
'invisible" as
they
are
tucked
away
at
home
struggling
to
manage
each
day.
How
many
can
afford
a
10
lakh
sip
and
puff
wheelchair
or
tilt
table
in
our
country.
The
reason
for
being
depressed
is
that
there
are
no
rehabilitation
centers
offering
holistic
services
to
face
life.
The
rehabilitation
at
physical,
psychological,
social,
vocational,
recreational
and
spiritual
levels
prepare
us
to
conduct
our
lives
and
also
achieve
a
lot
personally,
professionally
and
in
sports
(there
is
wheelchair
tennis,
basketball,
quad
rugby,
swimming
etc).
6.
Along
with
the
helplessness
of
rain
falling
on
ethan"s
face-
there
could
have
been
more
instances
of
enjoying
the
'fly
on
the
nose"
moments.
Spinal
injury
is
a
'real"
tough
issue.
Its
not
easy
either
living
with
paraplegia
or
quadriplegia.
Yet
it
is
hope
which
makes
us
rewrite
medical
books,
push
our
limits,
surprise
our
doctors
and
therapists.
All
the
stakeholders
work
towards
giving
spunk
back
to
our
spines
and
this
is
a
huge
healthcare
force.
They
too
are
disappointed
by
the
treatment
of
the
subject
and
ending
of
the
movie.
7.
And
finally,
Mr
Bhansali,
we
don"t
need
euthanasia
or
suicides
to
end
our
lives
in
India.
Poor
management
of
bed
sores,
urine
infections,
bowel
complications,
osteoporosis,
high
cost
of
ventilators
and
medication,
lack
of
trained
attendants
and
caregivers
and
lack
of
world
class
rehabilitation
centers
anyway
do
the
job,
unfailingly.
Even
today
in
Bollywood
hub,
Mumbai,
we
don"t
have
a
world
class
spinal
injury
rehabilitation
centre.
Charity
is
very
easy,
sponsoring
a
few
spinal
injured
is
simpler
but
getting
involved
with
interest
and
inspiring
our
friends
with
spinal
injury
is
the
need
of
the
hour.
Imagine,
our
children
and
young
friends
with
spinal
injury
watching
the
movie
with
their
devoted
parents
and
families.
The
fact
is
that
the
very
talented
Mr
Bhansali
makes
convincing
movies
on
different
aspects
of
disability;
we
would
like
positive
role
models
conveying
inspiring
messages
to
face
that
one
more
day
of
our
lives!
(The
writer
of
this
article
is
the
founder
of
Nina
Foundation,
an
NGO
that
helps
paraplegic
patients)