Madhur Bhandarkar dragged to court for copying story
News
oi-Kalyani Prasad Keshri
By Kalyani Prasad Keshri
Filmmaker
Madhur
Bhandarkar
was
still
trying
to
recover
from
the
shock
of
his
ambitious
project
Heroine
being
shelved
that
a
new
controversy
strikes
him.
Scriptwriter
Surendra
Tanwar
is
set
to
file
a
court
case
against
Bhandarkar
for
copying
one
of
his
stories
for
his
2009
film
Jail.
Tanwar
claims
film
Jail
is
based
on
'Gunahon
Ka
Devta',
a
story
registered
on
his
name
with
the
Film
Writers" Association
(FWA)
in
1999.
Tanwar
accuses
that
Madhur's
direction
Jail
made
in
2003
is
a
copy
of
his
story
picked
by
writer
Dilip
Shukla.
Surendra
was
formerly
employed
with
Shukla
as
an
assistant
writer.
After
Jail
released
in
2009
Surendra
was
surprised
to
see
the
similarity
between
his
story
and
the
film's
script,
therefore
he
filed
a
complaint
with
FWA.
Later
the
the
Disputes
Settlement
Committee
of
FWA
set
up
an
enquiry,
wherein
the
maker
with
the
writer
escaped
the
issue
claiming
that
Jail
was
based
on
the
Hollywood
films
like
Midnight
Express
and
Shawshank
Redemption.
Tanwar
counteracts
that
all
the
excuses
given
by
the
writer
and
Bhandarkar
are
untrue.
After
long
examination,
the
committee
concluded
that
Jail
was
a
copy
of
Tanwar's
script,
but
there
were
no
evidence
to
prove
it.
FWA
says
that
everybody
has
the
right
to
approach
the
court
for
his
or
her
right,
while
Madhur
remained
unavailable
for
the
comment.