Paltan
Movie
Review
|
J
P
Dutta
|
Arjun
Rampal
|
Dipika
Kakar
|
Gurmeet
|
FilmiBeat
Rating:
1.5/5
Star
Cast:
Arjun
Rampal,
Jackie
Shroff,
Sonu
Sood,
Harshvardhan
Rane,
Siddhanth
Kapoor
Director:
J
P
Dutta
JP
Dutta
is
a
name
synonymous
with
war
films
as
the
filmmaker
has
churned
out
a
couple
of
them
like
'Border',
'LOC:
Kargil' in
the
past.
But
what
happens
when
the
man
himself
seems
to
have
lost
his
mojo
and
comes
with
a
tiresome
watch
like
Paltan?
The
result
is
heart-breaking!
Inspired
by
true
events,
JP
Dutta's
latest
outing
is
based
on
the
Nathu
La
military
clashes
between
India
and
China
along
the
Sikkim
border
in
1967.
Paltan
opens
in
the
year
1962
where
the
Chinese
attack
the
Indian
soldiers
at
the
Namka
Chu
lake
in
Arunachal
Pradesh
and
as
many
as
1383
lives
are
lost.
The
scene
then
shifts
to
1967
where
we
get
to
witness
the
simmering
tension
between
India
and
China
at
the
Naathu
La
border
in
Sikkim.
The
film
narrates
the
story
of
how
our
Indian
forces
fought
an
intense
battle
to
ward
off
a
Chinese
infiltration.
At
the
same
time,
we
also
get
to
see
a
few
strokes
of
their
personal
lives
through
few
flashbacks.
While
the
idea
of
weaving
a
story
around
a
forgotten
history
looks
interesting
on
paper,
JP
Dutta
fails
miserably
when
it
comes
to
translating
his
vision
on
the
big
screen
in
the
form
of
'Paltan'.
The
film
looks
devoid
of
a
narrative.
Instead,
you
feel
like
you
have
waiting
in
the
cinema
hall
for
ages
for
something
to
transpire
on
screen.
The
screenplay
is
wobbly
and
lines
like,
'the
more
you
sweat
in
peace,
the
less
you
bleed
in
war' are
passed
off
as
dialogues.
Oops,
sorry
to
have
broken
your
heart
into
two!
Speaking
about
the
performaces,
Arjun
Rampal
as
Lt
Col.
Rai
Singh
and
Sonu
Sood
as
Major
Bishen
Singh
lead
the
pack,
but
hardly
pack
a
punch.
Harshvardhan
Rane
shows
a
glint
of
hope
in
few
scenes,
but
alas,
that's
short-lived.
On
the
hand,
Gurmeet
Chaudhary's
OTT
act
gets
on
your
nerves
after
few
minutes.
Luv
Sinha
is
terribly
wasted
while
Siddhant
Kapoor
gets
nothing
more
to
do
except
translate
Chinese
dialogues
for
the
men.
Jackie
Shroff
pops
up
here
and
there
in
few
scenes
just
to
make
you
realize
that
he's
also
a
part
of
the
flick.
Coming
to
the
leading
ladies,
sadly
they
just
end
up
as
mere
fillers
in
the
film.
While
Dipika
Kakkar
looks
straight
out
of
a
'Sasural
Simar
Ka'
sets,
Esha
Gupta
is
terribly
miscast.
On
the
other
end,
Sonal
Chauhan
is
just
restricted
to
few
glimpses
in
a
song.
Out
of
the
lot,
it's
Monica
Gill
who
shows
some
promise,
but
the
script
lets
her
down.
Shailesh
AV
Awasthhi
and
Nigam
Bomzan's
cinematography
is
average.
Ballu
Saluja's
editing
scissors
should
have
been
sharper.
Paltan
hardly
has
any
scope
for
music.
JP
Dutta's
Paltan
ends
up
as
a
poor
cousin
of
his
own
previous
film
'Border'
with
its
wafer-thin
plot
and
below-average
performances.
At
a
point
in
the
film,
Sonu
Sood
tells
a
fellow
soldier,
"Hamari
Paltan
ko..Bhagwan
ne
shayad
issi
kam
ke
liy
bheja
hai."
Unfortunately,
JP
Dutta's
soldiers
fail
miserably
in
their
mission
of
giving
us
an
emotional
fare.