The two had to perform once again so that the judges could decide their fate. Both actresses once again repeated their act. While Saroj chose Bhagyashree, Vaibhavi favoured Shilpa. The ultimate decision lied in Juhi's hand, who was in a soup to decide between Shilpa's namkeen number or Bhagyashree's seductive dance. Finally, Shilpa Shukla the Chak De girl edged Bhagyashree out of the contest.
Bhagyashree and Shilpa had bonded well in the few weeks they were together at the Jhalak House and wished well for each other. Bhagyashree was gracious in her exit. “The catch line of Jhalak Dikhhla Jaa asks –Aaj kya new kiya? I have done a lot of new things after coming to this show. I could not have imagined that I could do lifts ever. But I did. I am very happy. I will miss dancing," said the petite actress in her farewell.
Though Bhagyashree took her exit well, it was judge Juhi who felt sorry and was emotional. It was a sweet sight to see Bhagyashree consoling a teary eyed Juhi, when it should have been the other way round! Though all's well that end's well and now Bhagyashree will get back to her first priority – her family Watch some great dancing on Jhalak Dikhhla Jaa – Dancing with the stars 3 at 9 pm on Fridays and Saturdays only on Sony Entertainment Television