Recession
or
no
recession,
Bollywood
continues
to
attract
newcomers
in
hordes.
A
number
of
first-time
directors
tried
their
luck
this
year.
Some
succeeded,
some
didn't.
But
the
best
part
was
they
had
the
courage
to
swim
against
the
tide,
narrating
diverse
stories.
The
debutante
directors
who
created
a
solid
impact
this
year
included
Abbas
Tyrewala
(Jaane
Tu
Ya
Jaane
Na),
Kunal
Deshmukh
(Jannat),
Neeraj
Pandey
(A
Wednesday),
Rajkumar
Gupta
(Aamir)
and
Tarun
Mansukhani
(Dostana).
And,
if
one
may
add
one
more
name,
Abhishek
Kapoor
(Rock
On!!),
who,
after
tasting
failure
in
his
debut
film,
staged
a
comeback
with
his
second
film.
Ask
Abbas
Tyrewala
what
worked
with
the
viewers
and
he
replies
instantly,
"Jaane
Tu
Ya
Jaane
Na
was
more
of
a
nostalgic
trip.
You
went
back
to
the
days
when
you
weren't
burdened
with
the
responsibilities
of
life.
That
worked," he
admits.
Abhishek
Kapoor,
on
the
other
hand,
feels
that
ROCK
ON!!
worked
because
people
could
identify
with
its
story
and
the
life-like
performances
by
every
member
of
the
cast.
"If
I
had
to
make
Rock
On!!
all
over
again,
I'd
choose
the
same
cast.
I
can't
think
of
anyone
else
doing
justice
to
those
roles,"
he
remarks.
Rajkumar
Gupta,
the
man
behind
Aamir,
also
feels
that
Rajeev
Khandelwal
portrayed
the
character
with
amazing
precision.
However,
Rajeev
and
Rajkumar
have
decided
against
working
with
each
other
in
their
second
films.
Meanwhile,
Karan
Johar,
Tarun
Mansukhani's
mentor,
gives
Tarun
the
credit
for
thinking
out
of
the
box,
while
producers
Anjum
Rizvi
and
Shital
Bhatia
attribute
the
super-success
of
A
Wednesday
to
its
debutante
director
(Neeraj
Pandey)
as
also
the
superior
performances
by
stalwarts
Naseeruddin
Shah
and
Anupam
Kher.
Story first published: Tuesday, December 23, 2008, 15:48 [IST]