Aarakshan will be screened in Uttar Pradesh; SC's order
News
oi-Kalyani Prasad Keshri
By Kalyani Prasad Keshri
Giving
a
green
signal
to
Amitabh
Bachchan
starrer
Aarakshan
in
Uttar
Pradesh,
the
Supreme
Court
today
lifted
the
ban
imposed
by
the
state,
saying
that
public
discussion
and
conflict
are
necessary
in
a
vibrant
democracy
like
India.
A
bench
of
Justice
Mukundakam
Sharma
and
Justice
AR
Dave
lifted
the
two
months
ban
on
the
film
by
the
state
government.
The
courts
stated
that
the
restrictions
on
Aarakshan's
release
would
go
against
the
democratic
value
of
free
speech
and
expression
in
India.
Though
UP
was
adamant
to
fight
the
court's
decision,
Punjab
and
Andhra
Pradesh,
which
had
also
banned
the
screening
of
the
film,
told
the
court
that
they
have
decided
to
permit
the
release
of
Aarakshan.
"In
a
democracy,
particularly
in
a
vibrant
democracy
like
ours,
public
discussion
is
necessary
for
its
smooth
running.
In
fact,
such
discussions
bring
awareness
on
social
issues
for
effective
working
of
the
democracy.
In
fact,
when
there
is
such
public
discussion
and
dissent
there
would
be
a
informed
public
opinion
which
is
necessary
for
our
society,"
" said
the
bench,
while
writing
the
order.
The
apex
court
passed
the
order,
acting
on
the
writ
petition
filed
by
film
maker
Prakash
Jha
challenging
the
decision
of
UP,
Punjab
and
Andhra
Pradesh,
to
suspend
the
screening
of
the
film.
The
court
dismissed
the
argument
of
UP
counsel
UU
Lalit
that
the
film
would
lead
to
breach
of
law
and
order
in
the
state.
Lalit
also
argued
that
the
state
had
the
power
to
suspend
the
screening
in
the
interest
of
peace
in
the
state
even
if
the
film
has
been
passed
by
the
Central
Board
of
Film
Certification
(CBFC).
The
bench
stated
that
Aarakshan
has
already
been
screened
by
all
other
states
in
India,
including
those
which
are
considered
to
be
sensitive
to
these
feelings.
"It
is
for
the
state
to
maintain
law
and
order.
It
shall
maintain
law
and
order
effectively
and
in
a
meaningful
manner," the
bench
observed
agreeing
to
senior
counsel
Harish
Salve
for
the
producer,
that
the
state
can
suspend
the
screening
of
a
film
only
in
extraordinary
cases.
The
apex
court
also
cleared
that
the
high
level
committee
constituted
by
the
State
government,
which
viewed
Aarakshan
and
directed
deletion
of
a
few
scenes,
had
exercised
a
power
which
was
not
vested
with
it.
They
said
that
the
censorship
powers
was
vested
with
the
CBSE
alone.