Saand Ki Aankh Ageism Debate: Soni Razdan Says It Doesn’t Make Sense To Cast Young Actors
Soni Razdan questions the rationale behind Saand Ki Aankh’s casting and says it doesn’t make sense, especially when there are real 60-year-olds who can play those parts.
Saand
Ki
Aankh,
an
upcoming
movie
on
sharp
shooters
Chandro
and
Prakashi
Tomar,
has
sparked
the
ageism
debate
in
Bollywood.
The
film
will
star
Bhumi
Pednekar
and
Taapsee
Pannu,
both
in
their
thirties,
essaying
the
roles
of
sixty-somethings.
Although
the
film's
trailer
has
garnered
positive
reactions,
some
are
of
the
opinion
that
filmmakers
in
Bollywood
are
not
breaking
stereotypes
as
they
should
be.
Veteran
actress
Soni
Razdan
voiced
her
opinion
on
this
discussion,
saying
that
casting
young
actors
to
play
older
roles
makes
no
sense.
Talking
to
Quint,
Soni
questioned
the
rationale
behind
the
casting
of
Saand
Ki
Aankh.
She
said,
"I
love
both
these
actors
honestly
but
I
mean
why?
I
get
there
is
something
called
box
office
draw
but
then
why
make
a
film
on
60-year-olds
if
you
can't
cast
the
real
ones?"
She
continued
further,
"This
makes
no
sense.
I
think
it's
about
authenticity.
Would
The
Kominsky
Method
have
worked
with
30-year-olds?
It's
just
silly
beyond
a
point.
I
don't
know
the
script
and
that's
not
for
me
to
suppose.
I'm
just
saying
that
all
this
talk
of
Bollywood
breaking
out
of
the
stereotype
is
rubbish.
If
this
is
what
we
are
back
to
in
the
end.
One
film
-
Badhaai
Ho
-
doesn't
mean
a
stereotype
has
been
broken."
However,
Soni
also
believes
in
allowing
space
for
filmmakers
to
make
creative
decisions.
She
took
the
example
of
a
young
Anupam
Kher
playing
the
role
of
a
60-year
old
in
Saaransh,
a
movie
which
set
his
career
rolling.
So,
she
feels
it
is
not
fair
to
limit
a
director
when
making
a
film.
However,
she
added
that
given
the
reality
that
older
actors
are
limited
in
what
they
are
offered,
one
can't
help
feeling
this
way.
Neena
Gupta
had
started
this
debate
when
she
had
tweeted
that
actors
her
age
should
at
least
be
given
a
chance
to
play
roles
that
suit
them.
Directed
by
Tushar
Hiranandani
and
produced
by
Anurag
Kashyap,
Saand
Ki
Aankh
is
scheduled
for
release
on
October
25.