In
an
informal
chat
with
me
a
few
months
ago,
after
watching
Dunno
Y
Na
Jaane
Kyun
at
a
private
screening,
director
Sanjay
Sharma
enlightened
me
that
his
endeavour
in
making
the
film
is
to
drive
home
the
fact
that
there's
nothing
anomalous
about
being
homosexual.
"Through
this
film,
I
want
to
highlight
and
draw
attention
to
the
relationships
between
gay
people.
Their
sentiments
and
emotions.
The
idea
is
not
to
poke
fun
at
the
gay
community.
In
fact,
the
intent
is
to
make
a
film
that
looks
at
the
issue
and
the
gay
community
in
a
very
serious
perspective," he
remarked.
Very
noble
intentions,
I
must
pronounce,
but
do
the
gracious
objectives
of
the
director
that
he
sets
out
to
achieve
come
across
effectively
on
celluloid?
Does
the
film
come
across
as
an
emotional,
sensitive
and
a
ground-breaking
experience?
Let
me
attempt
to
examine...
Homosexuality
is
still
taboo
in
India
and
Dunno
Y
Na
Jaane
Kyun
attempts
to
tell
a
story
that's
shades
different
from
Fire
and
Girlfriend
or
even
Brokeback
Mountain.
Engaging
at
times,
but
amateurish
at
places,
the
film
has
the
courage
to
go
where
most
Hindi
films
have
not
dared
to
enter.
The
writing
[script:
Kapil
Sharma]
holds
your
interest
in
most
parts.
The
storyline
follows
a
gay
model
forced
to
compromise
his
morals
for
his
career.
He
then
forms
an
intimate
relationship
with
another
man,
who
is
already
married
and
lives
with
his
family.
It
would
be
interesting
to
see
whether
our
mainstream
Indian
audience
is
open
to
see
a
film
on
such
issues,
though
the
film
also
captures
the
multi-layered
relationship
within
an
Anglo-Indian
family.
Director
Sanjay
Sharma
has
handled
a
few
sensitive
sequences
well,
but
the
writing,
which
should've
focused
on
the
main
plot,
drifts
into
plots
of
the
numerous
family
members.
The
songs
are
melodious.
The
Lata
Mangeshkar
track
is
soothing
and
the
pick
of
the
lot.
Both
Kapil
Sharma
and
Yuvraaj
Parashar
come
up
with
sensitive
and
daring
performances.
The
film
marks
the
return
of
Zeenat
Aman
[excellent]
on
the
silver
screen,
besides
an
ensemble
cast
of
Helen
[good],
Rituparna
Sengupta
[first-rate],
Kabir
Bedi
[perfect],
Maradona
Rebello
[confident],
Aryan
Vaid
[okay],
Tara
Sharma
[alright],
Asha
Sachdev
[fair],
Hazel
[hardly
there],
Mahabanoo
Kotwal
[good],
Viveck
Vaswani
[adequate]
and
Parikshat
Sahni
[wasted].
On
the
whole,
Dunno
Y
Na
Jaane
Kyun
is
an
honest
attempt.
Sure,
it's
not
a
perfect
film,
but
at
least
it
makes
a
sincere
attempt
to
highlight
the
issue.
Director:
Sanjay
Sharma
Cast:
Aryan
Vaid,
Kapil
Sharma,
Maradona
Rebello,
Hazel,
Zeenat
Aman,
Helen,
Rituparna
Sengupta