Rating:
2.5/5
Star
Cast:
Rajkummar
Rao,
Kangana
Ranaut,
Amyra
Dastur,
Jimmy
Sheirgill,
Brijendra
Kala
Director:
Prakash
Kovelamudi
Judgemental
Hai
Kya
Movie
Review:
Kangana
Ranaut
|
Rajkummar
Rao
|
Ekta
Kapoor
|
FilmiBeat
Early
in
one
of
the
scenes
in
the
film,
when
Bobby's
boyfriend-cum-manager
cribs
to
her
about
the
status
quo
of
their
relationship,
she
shuts
him
up
by
asking
him
to
be
as
easy-going
and
adjusting
as
an
'aloo'.
Well,
just
like
a
'potato',
Kangana
Ranaut
easily
blends
into
the
quirky
world
of
Prakash
Kovelamudi's
'Judgementall
Hai
Kya'.
As
a
kid,
Bobby
(Kangana
Ranaut)
is
left
traumatized
when
her
parents' abusive
relationship
meets
a
fatal
end.
She
is
diagnosed
with
acute
psychosis
in
her
adult
years
and
even
ends
up
serving
some
time
in
the
asylum
on
the
charges
of
brutally
assaulting
a
co-worker.
Soon,
she
is
let
off
on
the
condition
that
she
would
continue
her
medication.
However,
things
take
a
awry
turn
when
a
picture-perfect
couple,
Keshav
(Rajkummar
Rao)
and
Reema
(Amyra
Dastur)
move
in
as
her
new
tenants
and
Bobby
finds
the
line
between
reality
and
imagination
blurring.
A
murder
takes
place
and
Bobby
and
Keshav
end
up
as
prime
suspects.
While
Bobby
is
hell-bent
that
Keshav
is
the
culprit,
the
latter
points
out
at
her
as
to
how
unreliable
mind
cannot
be
trusted.
The
rest
of
the
plot
revolves
around
how
the
two
indulge
in
a
cat-and-mouse
game
to
expose
the
shocking
truth.
While
the
concept
of
Judgementall
Hai
Kya
looks
rock-solid
on
paper,
Prakash
Kovelamudi
fails
to
have
a
tight
grip
on
the
direction.
His
bizarre,
psychedelic
world
is
alluring,
but
comes
across
as
a
drag
at
many
places.
Even
the
jolting
twist
in
the
climax
can
be
smelt
from
far
off
and
doesn't
leave
your
jaw
dropped.
Kanika
Dhillion's
screenplay
needed
to
be
a
lot
more
polished.
Too
much
of
abstract
motifs
in
the
second
half
is
a
big
turn
off.
Speaking
about
the
performances,
Kangana
Ranaut
seems
to
be
having
fun
with
her
character
and
one
cannot
miss
her
meta
moments
in
the
film.
As
Bobby,
the
actress
perfectly
captures
the
mind
of
a
deranged
woman
on
the
reel
and
makes
you
want
to
reach
out
to
tell
here
everything
is
going
to
be
alright.
Rajkummar
Rao
proves
why
he
is
one
of
the
best
talents
which
Bollywood
has
right
now.
He
looks
'smoking'
hot
and
his
glib-talker
act
leaves
you
mighty
impressed.
Together
with
Ms
Ranaut,
he
explodes
fireworks
on
the
big
screen.
Amyra
Dastur
and
Amrita
Puri
are
good
in
their
roles.
Hussain
Dalal
brings
in
some
humour
in
this
other-wise
ride.
Jimmy
Sheirgill
suffers
from
a
half-baked
role.
Pankaj
Kumar's
cinematography
perfectly
captures
the
dark
and
edgy
mood
of
the
film.
Nitin
Baid's
editing
could
have
been
a
little
more
tauter.
The
songs
of
'Judgementall
Hai
Kya'
fail
to
charm.
'Wakhra
Swag'
which
appears
during
the
end-credits
looks
misplaced.
Prakash
Kovelamudi
aims
to
play
mind
games
with
the
audience
with
the
turns
and
twists
in
his
narrative.
However,
the
latter
sees
through
them
quite
early.
While
the
trailer
promised
a
gripping
murder-mystery,
the
film
fails
to
meet
the
expectation
levels
and
leaves
you
heartbroken.
I
am
going
with
2.5
stars.