"It wasn't instant love with David. We met on a blind date at a restaurant with a group of other people. We didn't speak to each other that night," Contactmusic quoted her, as saying. "He talked to my sister and I talked to his friend. And he and my sister seemed to be hitting it off so I thought maybe we should set them up instead. But the friend said don't you dare," she added.
Pfeiffer, who has two children, 14-year-old adopted daughter Claudia Rose and 13-year-old biological son John Henry, with Kelley, said that the pair got on well right away when they got some time alone together. "We finally had a date where it was just the two of us, and here we are," she said.