It
is
a
win
for
Angelina
Jolie
after
a
California
appeals
court
disqualified
a
private
judge
who
was
overlooking
Angelina
and
Brad
Pitt's
divorce
case.
According
to
a
news
report
in
The
Guardian,
the
second
district
court
of
appeal
was
in
agreement
with
Jolie
on
Friday
(July
23)
that
Judge
John
W
Ouderkirk
did
not
disclose
business
relationships
with
Brad's
attorneys.
According
to
the
report,
the
court
ruled,
"Judge
Ouderkirk's
ethical
breach,
considered
together
with
the
information
disclosed
concerning
his
recent
professional
relationships
with
Pitt's
counsel,
might
cause
an
objective
person,
aware
of
all
the
facts,
reasonably
to
entertain
a
doubt
as
to
the
judge's
ability
to
be
impartial.
Disqualification
is
required."
This
has
resulted
in
the
custody
fight
over
the
couple's
children
starting
all
over
again.
The
judge
had
already
announced
Angelina
Jolie
and
Brad
Pitt
to
be
divorced
but
had
separated
the
issues
regarding
the
custody
of
their
child.
The
Mr
and
Mrs
Smith
stars
had
also
hired
their
own
lawyers
for
more
privacy
in
the
case.
Angelina
Jolie's
attorneys
had
appealed
after
her
request
for
disqualification
of
Judge
John
W
Ouderkirk
was
declared
too
late
by
a
lower
court
judge.
The
oral
arguments
in
front
of
the
appeals
court
that
took
place
on
July
9,
had
focused
on
which
rules
should
be
applied
to
private
judges.
According
to
the
report,
Angelina's
attorney
Robert
Olsen
had
stated,
"If
you're
going
to
play
the
role
of
a
paid
private
judge
you
have
to
play
by
the
rules
and
the
rules
are
very
clear,
they
require
full
transparency.
Matters
that
should
have
been
disclosed
were
not
disclosed."
The
panel's
ruling
only
applied
to
Judge
John
W
Ouderkirk,
but
they
also
questioned
whether
such
an
arrangement
should
be
allowed
in
California.
The
attorneys
of
Angelina
Jolie
and
Brad
Pitt
did
not
have
any
comment
on
the
ruling
on
an
immediate
basis.
Talking
about
the
former
couple's
case,
Angelina
and
Brad
were
married
for
12
years
until
Jolie
filed
for
divorce
in
the
year
2016.
The
two
were
officially
declared
divorced
in
the
year
2019
in
April
after
their
respective
lawyers
called
for
a
judgement
that
allows
them
to
be
declared
single,
while
other
matters
like
child
custody
and
finances
are
pending.