Oneindia
Writes...
Sana
Khan
doesn't
have
much
to
show
except
her
skin,
which
she
bares
as
if
there
is
no
tomorrow.
While
she
is
over-the-top
in
few
scenes
and
rock
solid
in
other,
on
the
whole,
you
don't
see
a
powerful
performance
that
should
have
ideally
stunned
the
audiences.
It
would
be
an
insult
to
Smitha
if
Sana
was
even
compared
to
her
because
sensuality
is
not
about
baring
everything.
Rediff
Writes...
Though
quite
attractive,
Sana
Khan
has
failed
to
bring
out
the
sophisticated
sultry
sexiness
that
was
the
trademark
of
Silk
Smitha.
Well,
what
our
readers
say?
Follow
in
the
next
two
slides...
A
Fan
Writes
A
reader
named
Raja
writes,
"Sana
Khan
is
no
match
to
Vidya
Balan.
The
narration
and
her
acting
have
played
spoilsport."
A
Fan
Writes
A
reader
named
Subramanya
writes,
"Disappointing.
I
expected
the
film
to
be
good
considering
that
the
Hindi
biopic
was
a
remarkable
film.
But
this
is
poorly
made
film."
Nadigayin
Diary
Anthony
Eastman,
who
introduced
Silk
to
the
Malayalam
film
industry,
wrote
the
script
for
the
film.
"Based
on
real
experiences
that
he
shared
with
the
actress,
he
penned
the
story
with
lot
of
detailing
and,
therefore,
it
is
different
from
other
versions,"
the
director
of
the
film
had
said
earlier.
But
it
has
neither
worked
in
Malayalam
nor
in
Tamil.