Rating:
2.5/5
Star
Cast:
Vikram,
Jayam
Ravi,
Karthi,
Trisha
Krishnan,
Aishwarya
Rai
Bachchan
Director:
Mani
Ratnam
Raja,
rani,
senapati,
guptchar,
sautela
bhai,
rajkumar,
rajkumari,
rajkumari
ki
saheli
-
All
of
these
and
more
came
together
in
Rajkumar
Kohli's
ensemble
affair
set
around
kings
and
their
kingdoms
back
in
1984.
A
masala
potboiler,
the
film
has
managed
a
superbly
impressive
ensemble
of
Dharmendra,
Raaj
Kumar,
Sunil
Dutt,
Hema
Malini,
Kamal
Haasan,
Reena
Roy,
Pran,
Ranjeet
and
Ajit
amongst
others
in
principal
roles.
Released
almost
four
decades
back,
the
film
was
perhaps
the
last
such
big
Bollywood
film
with
this
kind
of
stage,
setting
and
arena
that
worked
at
the
box
office.
In
south
though,
this
genre
is
still
popular
and
time
and
again
filmmakers
do
go
back
in
time
to
make
such
period
dramas
set
around
kingdoms.
Mani
Ratnam
has
attempted
that
with
this
two
part
film
Ponniyin
Selvan,
simply
put
as
PS.
PS
1
has
released
now
and
after
almost
three
hour
of
(an
uneven)
narrative,
it
is
announced
that
PS2
would
release
in
2023.
The
film,
as
it
turns
out,
is
rather
inconsistent
in
its
storytelling
and
one
ends
up
wondering
that
is
it
because
of
lack
of
knowledge
around
Chola
kingdom
history
or
whether
the
storytelling
is
actually
all
over
the
place.
Considering
the
fact
that
a
solid
A
team
has
come
together
to
create
this
magnum
opus,
be
it
director
Mani
Ratnam,
editor
Sreekar
Prasad,
cinematographer
Ravi
Verman
or
the
man
who
keeps
it
all
together,
A.
R.
Rahman,
you
are
kes
to
believe
that
there
was
a
solid
idea
in
place
which
enticed
them
all.
However
the
execution
leaves
a
lot
to
be
desired.
The
film
starts
off
rather
suddenly
with
a
battle
sequence
and
Anil
Kapoor's
voiceover
(in
the
Hindi
version)
tries
to
familiarise
audience
with
the
core
premise.
An
attempt
is
certainly
been
made
but
then
the
story
is
so
rooted
in
south
history
that
the
names,
places
and
events
turn
out
to
be
very
unfamiliar.
In
fact
this
is
how
things
stay
right
through
the
length
of
the
film
since
that
the
premise
is
lost
for
the
non-south
audience.
Even
otherwise,
the
execution
has
a
lot
of
ups
and
downs.
So
at
times
you
are
excited
especially
around
sequences
which
revolve
around
politics
coming
into
place
and
coups
being
planned.
On
the
other
hand
there
are
many
forced
comic
sequences
that
are
not
just
non-contextual
but
also
lengthy.
Moreover,
at
times
you
are
totally
lost
on
the
intentions
and
the
actions
of
some
of
the
principle
characters.
One
expected
Vikram
to
lead
the
show
right
through
but
he
is
there
primarily
at
the
beginning,
interval
point
and
then
some
parts
of
the
second
half.
In
fact,
it's
Karthi
who
takes
over
the
mantle
as
the
leading
man
and
it's
nice
to
see
him
in
a
light
hearted
avtar
after
I
caught
him
last
in
Kaithi.
He
is
easy
and
breezy
with
his
performance
that
works
for
the
film.
What
also
works
is
the
grace
that
Aishwarya
Rai
Bachchan
brings
to
screen.
She
has
a
very
meaty
role
too
which
justifies
her
comeback
in
a
part
that
also
goes
well
with
her
age.
Trisha
is
also
likewise
with
her
grace,
though
somehow
her
characterisation
is
unidimensional,
when
one
would
have
expected
a
better
range.
Jayam
Ravi
makes
a
late
entry
but
then
holds
the
screen
well
with
a
promise
of
bringing
a
lot
more
in
PS2.
One
can
sense
that
from
the
core
storyline
perspective,
PS1
had
a
good
base
to
it
which
could
have
been
explored
to
the
fullest.
However
somehow
it's
the
visuals
and
the
sound
which
stay
with
you
more
than
the
script.
Action
sequences
are
nice
with
satisfactory
VFX
coming
into
play.
Cinematography
is
glossy.
Production
design
is
lavish
with
budget
showing
on
screen.
Background
score
is
good
though
songs
are
way
too
many
and
also
not
the
popular
kind.
From
the
popularity
standpoint,
the
film
is
primarily
for
the
south
market
where
Tamil
audience
would
be
able
to
relate
to
it
far
better.
No
wonder,
it
has
taken
a
good
start
at
the
box
office
there.
In
Hindi
too,
it
has
actually
taken
a
fair
opening
though
it
has
to
be
seen
how
do
things
go
over
the
weekend
and
then
beyond
that.
For
those
who
want
to
catch
a
movie
solely
for
the
purpose
of
big
screen
entertainment
without
worrying
much
about
the
context
and
the
history
per
se,
PS1
makes
for
a
fair
watch.
As
for
those
looking
forward
to
pure
masala
with
a
narrative
that's
more
straight
forward,
catch
Raaj
Tilak.